← Back

A History of Productivity: Lessons from Success and Failure

Successful Examples of Automation

  1. Ford Motor Company (1913)
    Automation Type: Assembly Line

    • Summary: Henry Ford introduced the moving assembly line for automobile production, reducing the time to produce a Model T from 12 hours to 90 minutes.
    • Result: Mass production became viable, making cars affordable for the average consumer and revolutionizing manufacturing industries worldwide.

  2. Toyota Production System (1960s)
    Automation Type: Lean Manufacturing and Robotics

    • Summary: Toyota integrated Just-In-Time (JIT) inventory and automation in its production lines using robots like the PUMA (Programmable Universal Machine for Assembly).
    • Result: Improved efficiency, reduced waste, and became a global benchmark for automotive production.

  3. Amazon Warehousing (2012)
    Automation Type: Robotic Picking Systems

    • Summary: Amazon acquired Kiva Systems to automate product storage and retrieval in its warehouses. Robots transport shelves to human workers, streamlining the process.
    • Result: Improved order fulfillment speed and reduced labor costs, enabling Amazon’s rapid growth.

  4. Tesla’s Gigafactories (2010s)
    Automation Type: Highly Automated Car Manufacturing

    • Summary: Tesla incorporated extensive robotics and AI for electric vehicle production in its Gigafactories.
    • Result: High precision and scalability for EV production, but with some hiccups in overly ambitious early automation (discussed below).

Failures of Automation

  1. Tesla’s “Alien Dreadnought” Automation Plan (2018)
    Automation Type: Over-reliance on Robotics

    • Summary: Tesla aimed for nearly 100% automation in Model 3 production but encountered bottlenecks when robots failed to handle complex tasks like wiring assembly.
    • Result: Production delays and increased costs forced Tesla to reintroduce human workers, highlighting the need for balance between human and robotic capabilities.

  2. Foxconn’s Robotics Rollout (2011)
    Automation Type: Robotic Manufacturing for Electronics

    • Summary: Foxconn planned to replace a significant portion of its workforce with robots but faced challenges with high costs, technical issues, and inability to manage delicate tasks.
    • Result: Robots were unable to fully replace skilled labor, and the initiative was scaled back.

  3. UK NHS “Care Robots” (2010s)
    Automation Type: Robotics in Healthcare

    • Summary: The NHS trialed robots for routine patient care, such as medication delivery and lifting patients, but found they lacked emotional intelligence and adaptability.
    • Result: Poor patient outcomes and resistance from healthcare workers led to the abandonment of the program.

  4. Boeing 777 Production Automation (2015)
    Automation Type: Automated Assembly Systems

    • Summary: Boeing tried using robotic systems to fasten fuselages, but the robots struggled with precision and caused damage to components.
    • Result: Boeing reverted to human workers for some tasks, blending automation with manual labor.

Key Takeaways

Success Factors:

  1. Incremental Adoption: Successful cases like Ford and Toyota phased in automation with pilot testing and continuous improvement.
  2. Human-Machine Collaboration: Balancing human skills and robotics maximizes efficiency, as seen in Amazon’s warehouses.
  3. Context-Aware Deployment: Automation should align with operational realities, avoiding over-reliance on technology.

Common Pitfalls in Failures:

  1. Over-Ambition: Unrealistic goals for 100% automation, as in Tesla and Foxconn, often lead to inefficiency and delays.
  2. Neglecting Human Factors: Resistance from employees or inadequate training can derail automation efforts, as in the NHS.
  3. Inadequate Testing: Deploying systems without sufficient testing in real-world conditions, such as Boeing’s fuselage automation, can lead to costly errors.

Automation can drive transformative success but requires careful planning, realistic goals, and a balanced approach to ensure a positive outcome.